Peanut Butter & Jelly Cake

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cake | Nostalgic Custom Birthday Cake

Product Overview

Our Peanut Butter & Jelly Cake takes a beloved childhood favorite and turns it into a celebration-worthy dessert, with soft, fluffy layers infused with rich peanut butter and a sweet fruit filling folded in between. It's a playful, comforting flavor combination that always brings a smile. Made to order in our Chestnut Hill kitchen, it's a fun alternative to the traditional birthday cake.

Customize Your Cake

• Pricing: The listed price is a starting point for our classic size and flavor. Because every cake is made to order, we confirm your final price with a personalized quote based on your size, flavor, and any customizations you choose. Contact us to get your quote.
• Customizable Size: Available in a range of sizes to fit your gathering, starting with our standard 8-inch round up to a generous 10-inch round. Larger sizes may be arranged as a single tier or a multi-tier design for bigger celebrations. Just let us know your headcount and we'll help you choose.
• Signature Flavor: Peanut Butter & Jelly is the star of this cake. It's a rich blend of soft peanut butter-infused layers and sweet fruit jelly filling for that classic PB&J taste in every bite. Want a different base or filling instead? Just ask and we'll happily customize it for you.
• Custom Frosting Color: The buttercream frosting can be customized to your preferred color palette, so your cake matches your event's theme or the recipient's favorite colors.
• Optional Cake Topper: Add a custom round paper topper with a personalized message, name, or graphic for birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, or any special milestone. Available for a small additional fee.
• Handcrafted Note: Because each cake is handcrafted to order, exact decoration placement, shade, and piping detail may vary slightly from the photos shown. That's the nature of handmade work.

Standard Size & Serving Guide

Our classic Peanut Butter & Jelly Cake (8-inch) is a two-layer buttercream cake that comfortably serves 16-20 as a dessert-style slice. A larger 10-inch round serves about 24-28. For bigger celebrations, we can arrange a multi-tier design. Let us know your guest count and we'll recommend the right size.

A Playful Twist on a Childhood Favorite

Perfect for the peanut butter lover in your life, this cake brings a fun, nostalgic flavor to any celebration. Order ahead by appointment and let our bakers whip up this playful favorite for you.